Once upon a time, when Gretta was a toddler, I told her to trust me and then I nearly drowned her — at which point the heaviest fear I’ve ever felt set in. It was like some God of Terrifying Things was holding me by my ankles and plastering papier-mache-panic upon my body piece by piece, and I was paralyzed but for the involuntary shaking. It wasn’t just that she could have been seriously hurt on my watch, but also that I’d forgotten, for one dazzling moment, to be afraid of everything — and I’d been punished for it. Remarkably, that day, after the shock dripped off, I did what I knew had to be done, for both of us. I forced us back in the water.
Two days ago, I dove headfirst back into blogging, the whole unfathomably large, salty, mysterious, oceanic thing, the feed readers and the stats and ads and designs and community. I jackknifed from the high dive and felt that mind-numbing rush upon impact, fresh and startling, heart-stopping. I have yet to decide if it’s a baptism or a drowning.
I don’t know why I have such a fear of this place. The thing I didn’t say in that Stepping Off post, the thing only a few people know, is that I got scared. There’s a reason I live in the country, twenty miles from the nearest gas station. Sure, it’s scenic, but it’s also private. Very, very private. When the Okay, Fine, Dammit house became a more popular place to be, I was absolutely thrilled. All a writer wants is to be read and heard and trusted and followed, you all know that. But it also felt like there were suddenly all these faces peeking in the windows, and I’d never even thought to buy blinds. Please don’t misunderstand: I invited you, you’re all welcome, I just have to get used to wearing pants, you know?
More than that, though, is the fear of being hated, of being talked about, of being judged. I’ve had only a handful of inconsequential trolls since starting this blog, and though they were mostly drive-by, inane posters, they affected me all the same. And for those other Big Bloggers, the ones who have really made it, the ones who supposedly have what we all want, things are so much worse.
Last night I spent two hours glued to a hate blog, the kind of thing I didn’t know existed until I accidentally stumbled upon it and couldn’t look away. Imagine, an entire blog devoted to bashing Dooce and Pioneer Woman, and others like them. The blog author spewed some of the most rancid vitriol I’ve ever tasted in my life, and it struck me, hard, like a slap: Is this the ultimate goal?
Is that how you’re rewarded when you’ve finally “made it” as a blogger? To get to a place where so many people read you that there are bound to be several who hate you, and dedicate their entire lives to ripping you to shreds bit by bit? Are we all just wishing for traffic and comments and recognition without thinking about the consequences? I know it’s insane, but if I couldn’t tear my eyes away from that blog, how on earth could I possibly ignore any bad things that could be written about me? It doesn’t matter how big or small or in between this blog is, even one sharp sentence will slice me. I know it. And I’m terrified.
But look at me, I’m doing it anyway — and I guess that’s the difference between me today and me two days ago.
Like any good parent, I often wonder if I permanently damaged Gretta that day in the pool. I can still see her face, wet, shiny, open to me, open to the world, plastered with a smile that threatened to split her face apart. The subtle ways it morphed from joy to terror and back to joy again, over and over as we tossed her into the air. The weightless nanoseconds before she came back down, time suspended. How she looked when I betrayed her trust.
She was sitting in one of those flotation devices for babies, shaped like a turtle or a dragon or something, and there were two of us, two adults, a friend and I, one on each side, protective, fun, and it was a game, and she was safe, we’re here, don’t worry! We kept shouting, laughing along with her, until one throw was too high, and out she slipped, and down she plunged, and for several terrifying seconds I waded through molasses to get to her, to pull my baby from the three-foot depths. We climbed out of the pool and clung to its edge, shaken, changed, maybe forever, maybe for a minute, I don’t know. We sunk into each other, into the pavement, the grainy poolside putty leaving a pocked impression upon the backs of my thighs, the experience itself leaving one more nebulous. I wanted to wrap her in a towel and get her out of there, run till my legs gave out, but something bigger than me told me what I had to do, even if it was on auto-pilot. That if we hid from this fear, any fear — hers more primal, mine laden with knowledge and worry and experience — it might be crippling.
That is why, after some cuddling and hushing and sweet, slow rocking, without knowing exactly what we were doing or what would come of it, we slipped back into the water.
*****
This post was inspired by my dear friend Katie’s post today, about getting back on the horse (literally). I started to write a book in her comment section and then decided to come over here, instead. I’d forgotten about this experience until I read her words.